Friday, December 10, 2010

Effect of a Chinese Slowdown?

I would like to point to an article this week by one of my favorite Chinese economics bloggers, Michael Pettis, formerly a Wall Street trader and now a professor at Beijing University's Guanghua School of Management. Pettis's recent post on the effects of a possible Chinese economic slowdown provides a fascinating comparison to the similar slowdown suffered by the Japanese during the 1990s.

In the article, he argues that a slowdown of the Chinese economy as it makes the necessary transition to a domestic consumption model of growth is unlikely to create neither a massive slowdown in world growth nor widespread political instability.

Like Japan during the 1980s, the Chinese economy has in recent decades produced incredible economy growth figures and equally impressive trade surpluses as its export driven economic behemoth manufactures products for markets around the world. Its contribution to world demand, however, like Japan during its growth spurt, remains relatively small. Because, Pettis and other economists argue, world economy growth is driven by demand, not supply, a slowdown in the Chinese economy is more likely to affect China than it is to disrupt global growth.

Moreover, Pettis argues, a massive economy slowdown is unlikely to produce widespread political instability in China because, like Japan, China's current growth model relies on subsidizing industry at the expense of domestic consumption by keeping its currency undervalued and interest rates on savings deposits low. A slowdown caused by a transition to a domestic consumption driven economy model would certainly hurt the domestic economy and GDP per capita, but it would not necessary coincide with decreased domestic consumption. Pettis argues that despite the dismal growth in Japan during the 1990s, consumption per capita increased at a rate much faster than GDP. Japanese households, then, did not feel as bad off as one might expect given GDP growth.

Overall, the article does a good job of comparing these two economy development stories. China, of course, took over where Japan left off in the 1990s when a Japanese asset bubble popped and the island nation suffered a lost decade of deflation and dismal growth. Since then, the Middle Kingdom has grown by leaps and bounds, this year finally supplanting Japan as the second largest economy in the world after the United States. Whether another economy stands ready to take over where China left off, however, remains unclear. India, a developing nation of roughly the same size, is often mentioned as a natural successor. Its economy record, however, leaves much doubt of whether it is yet capable of such rapid growth.

Of course, some argue China's slowdown may never come. With the nation seemingly unscathed by the global financial crisis, some optimists believe the Chinese will continue to chug forward and eventually overtake the United States. I am doubtful. These same optimists, after all, said the same thing about Japan.

No comments:

Post a Comment